I think we've all been there in our crafting journey. We faithfully make that little tension square, measuring our stitches and rows for reasons that may seem pretty esoteric and mysterious and then, well, what's the point? The swatch always lies anyway! My sweater is too big/too small/ too short but somehow too wide?! So why waste time on the swatch if it's not going to work out in the end anyway? I may as well eyeball it!
The problem is, patterns always seem to assume you know how to swatch, but do you? Is the correct method to create the exact number of stitches and rows as asked for and measure how they turn out? Are you supposed to use edge stitches to prevent curling? And actually, wait, what stitch is the gauge stitch anyway? Does it matter? And what hook/needles should I use? The pattern says one thing, but the ball band says another. Which one is right? I will answer all these questions and more to make sure that not only do your swatches never lie to you again, but that you will be confidant enough to make your own swatches and use them to make decisions about your projects. Swatching will transform from a boring chore before you get to the real fun - the project! - to a fun activity all on it's own. So first...
What is a swatch, anyway?
If you've ever been to a hardware store, you've probably seen the section where they have the little pieces of paper with the different paint colors available, and their names. Those are paint swatches. Or maybe you've ordered fabric or yarn online and asked for (or possibly received as a freebie) a card or booklet of the fabric or yarn, sometimes called a color card, sometimes called a sample booklet, and sometimes called, yes!, a swatch book! Or if you've taken classes in fine art, you've probably had to swatch paints, inks, or markers before.
A swatch is simply a sample of something, which you use to get a feel for it, and to make decisions with. With paint swatches, you take it home into the room you're thinking of painting, to see how the light in the room makes the color appear. With yarn and fabric swatches, you receive a small sample so you can see the colors, the drape, the texture. Sometimes the samples are big enough that you can wash them and see how they behave before and after. With paint, inks, and markers, you test how they apply, how they layer, how they dry. But what does any of this have to do with knitting and crochet?
Well, a gauge swatch (or tension square to my friends across the sea) is a sample you're making to see and test the gauge of your work. If you're trying to match a pattern exactly, getting the exact gauge the pattern writer specifies is important. On the other hand, once you become an old hand at swatching, the need to slavishly get gauge diminishes. If you like the fabric you're making with your tools and yarn, but it doesn't match the pattern gauge, this is not an issue for you; you can use your swatch to see how your work behaves, compare it with what you want to copy, and do some grade school math to obtain the same results, but with the fabric you like, rather than the fabric the author got.
So, how is this possible? And why have my swatches always lied in the past?
It's All a Matter of Technique
The key to making swatches that don't lie is pretty obvious once you realize it, but until you do, it's an enigma. In order to get the results you want, you have to make a swatch that mimics what you're going to make. In other words, you have to use the same materials and tools to create the same fabric, at the same gauge or tension (meaning, stitch size), using the same stitch, and using the same technique you'd like to use in your project. It's no use swatching in stockinette with a garter stitch edging if what you plan to make has lace, cables, or colorwork. If you had made a stockinette square bounded by garter stitch, the swatch would have prepared you perfectly. However, absent that situation, it cannot have possibly given you the information you needed. Similarly, if you crochet the exact number of stitches and rows called for in the gauge section, even if you do use the exact stitch called for, this swatch will still lie to you. The fabric you are going to be working will be much bigger, with more stitches all around. If you have 1 or 2 inches of fabric, how can you see how it will drape? How it will stretch? Sometimes even have the pattern will look when repeated across the color gradient of your yarn? Simply put, you can't. You have to create something bigger than what you'd like to measure, in order to see how it will behave. The common answer is "at least 6 square inches" and if you're working in DK to worsted weight yarn with tools to produce a fabric that's neither loose nor tight, then this is probably right. But if your yarn is larger than worsted, it might take an even larger swatch to see how the fabric will behave; on the other hand, I often do just 2-4 inch square swatches when working with lace to fingering weight yarns, because the number of stitches required to make a 6 inch square approaches the prohibitive and at this weight, 2-4 inches of fabric is multiple repeats in both directions anyway. So, what do good and bad swatches look like? I have compiled a little gallery of my own swatches below, for the more visual learners.
Swatches that are big fat liars
This was a swatch for a hat. The hat was not to be stockinette with garter all around, nor even worked flat, so this swatch did not help me. I measured from garter edge to garter edge, both width- and height-wise, and used those numbers. However, you can see in the photo the way the sides bow in and the top and bottom flare out? That is because garter stitch and stockinette do not take up the same amount of space. A garter ridge (that is, 2 rows of garter stitch) is shorter but fatter than the same 2 rows of stockinette, which is comparatively taller and narrower. The two push and pull on each other, distorting both of their dimensions, which means when I moved on to the hat, my math was wrong. My swatch lied! Or, did it? I was asking this swatch a different question than the one I should have asked it. It didn't lie!

This would be fine if all I was testing was color placement. But this was for a cardigan, so I was also questioning how many to cast on, what shaping rates I would need, etc. I thought I had solved my original problem, because I made the swatch big enough that I could measure a 1 inch square in the center, away from the edges, and "avoid" the distortion. But the stripes allow you to see that the buckling and distortion carries across the entire row. Making the swatch bigger will not work until the swatch is big enough that you may as well have simply cast on a sleeve (more on that later!) Did my swatch lie? No, I was once again asking it the wrong questions.
I do not have lying crochet swatches to show, because I am embarrassed to report that the swatching I did back in those days mostly consisted of "chain until it's 'long enough' work one row, and figure out the math from there." This is fine for things like blankets or hot pads, and terrible for anything else. Thankfully, I figured things out before I started trying to crochet things where the size matters. But these same pitfalls apply to crochet too. If the pattern calls for filet crochet, swatching in double crochet is not "basically the same thing" and will not give you the numbers you need, Similarly, trying to make a square that matches the 1, 2, or 4 inch numbers will not work out in the larger project unless all you are doing is one stitch, back and forth, with no shaping, and even then it can be wrong because the way you hold a 2 inch project and the way you hold a sweater project is vastly different, and can change your tension. It sounds silly, I know, but if you've ever had a crochet swatch "lie" to you after trying to swatch this way, then you already have proof that this is true.
So, what does a good swatch look like? This is a bit like that Tolstoy quote; good swatches are good swatches for the same reasons, but bad swatches? They're all bad in their own unique ways.
A Good Swatch
The main thing about swatches that don't lie is that is closely resembles what you plan to make. If you are going to work in the round, so too must be your swatch. If you are going to be working lace, or cables, or mosaic crochet, or whatever, then the swatch also must be too. It must be big enough so you can see what it will look and behave like, it must be washed the way you plan to wash the finished project to avoid growing or shrinking or bleeding surprises, and most importantly, it must be measurable. You will note that I never say "it must be 6 inches square" because in all honesty, some of the best swatches I've ever made were abandoned at an inch or so in. This was just long enough to tell me that something about it wasn't working; maybe I didn't think the yarn meshed well with the stitch, or I found this hook impossible to work with, or actually this is not a color I would wear on a hat. These swatches are just as valuable as the ones I've finished, because they saved me potentially hours of time working on a project that was doomed to fail anyway. In the gallery below, I have included such a swatch, and the reason for it, to give you an idea of when it's time to bail on a swatch.

This was an excellent swatch. I used the exact yarn and needles I was going to use in my project, with the exact stitches I planned to use, in the order I planned to use them. It allowed me to "preview" my hat, see how it draped, how the transition between the two stitches looked, let me determine if there would be any flipping or curling at the transition point, etc. The math checked out with this one, because I asked the swatch the right questions.

Another excellent swatch, looking different, but good for the same reason. I was testing both color placement and yarn suitability in these swatches, for a sweater. The swatch on the left won out for me, but they're both good. I was able to see that the brown and blue behaved differently as ribbing, even though they were worked on the same needles, and also behaved differently as lace; the brown seems more open, compared to the blue. from this, I was able to get accurate numbers for all three major parts of the sweater: the lace portion at the collar, the stockinette for most of the body, and the ribbing for the hem and cuffs. They have different gauges which distort each other, which may seem like an issue but the lace will transition to the stockinette, and the stockinette to the ribbing, and it's important to get measurements on how they distort each other in order to know what, if any, measures to take to equalize them. Not shown, but I did also work a swatch of just stockinette in order to see how it differed from the small transition zone in this swatch, and changed my numbers accordingly.

This crochet swatch taught me two things: the first was that I liked the look of the circle better in single crochet as opposed to half double crochet and the second was that this yarn was too splitty to crochet with. This is an equally valid end to a swatch! Rather than embark on the larger, motif based blanket I was intending to make, I unwound this yarn and used it for what it would eventually become: a knit sweater. Additionally, you can see that it's on a paper towel, because this is a yarn I'd never used before. I had no idea whether the dyes from this dyehouse were wash fast in my water and soap; alkalinity, hardness, and the presence of additives like fluoride or chlorine in the water and protein scrubbers or optical brighteners in the soap can change the fastness of a dye - it is not necessarily a sign of poor workmanship if a skein bleeds in your wash, especially if it seems to happen to every skein. So these swatches also taught me that this dye will not bleed in my wash water, an important consideration if I wanted to use it with lighter yarns.
This is a swatch I did for a mitten. I was curious if my idea for a ruffle at the wrist end of the mitten would work. I did not photograph it, but I finished the ruffle in the way I intended to, and the portion of the mitten you can see here is from my ideal cast on up to the thumb shaping. I played around with the proportions and whether the type of cast off mattered. I knit this portion in total at least 3 times, learning something different each time, that informed how I eventually made the mittens. In this case, had I wanted to, I could have then simply continued on with the mittens from the original direction, but I unraveled it and started over because there were changes I wanted to make to the cast on. However, this is proof of concept of something I will talk about further down, which is that sometimes the project itself can be the swatch.

At this resolution it can be hard to see the detail, so click the photo to enlarge it if needed. This is a swatch for a sock, so it was completed in the round, with 3 different needle sizes. I did one row of purl so it would be easier to visually differentiate which sections are in what needle. You can also see that I washed this still attached to the ball. I rarely cut the thread for my knits because I rarely use superwash, so my projects are not going in the machine. I simply put the swatch in the wash bucked and leave the ball sitting next to it. The water does wick some way towards the ball, but it never actually reaches it and if I'm careful to keep the ball dry, it doesn't impact the washing or drying time of the swatch at all. You can also see that unlike the sweater project with a lot of stockinette, this one curls. It's because of the tightness of the gauge; socks require the finest gauge you can muster if you'd like them to have any lasting power, and that causes the stockinette to curl no matter what you do. It's fine to pin the swatch just enough to hold it in place while you measure your gauge, but do not stretch it and pin it to dry that way unless you intend to do that to the finished object, too. It seems like a good idea to make measuring easier, but it leads to a situation where the swatch "lies" because the fabric you measured isn't the fabric you ended up making.
You can do this with crochet, too. The reason it narrows heading to the right is that each stripe is made with a different size hook. This swatch was serving double duty as color placement demo as well. Combining things like this wherever possible is a great way to save time, if part of the tedium of swatching is time spent away from the best part of any project - starting! - is what's holding you back.
The Evolution of a Swatch
This is a series of swatches from idea to final project, to give you an idea of how a swatch can and should work for you, and how you can use it for more than just getting gauge on your patterns, but for making your own projects and patterns from ideas.
I knew I wanted to use these two colors together, and I wanted it to have some level of color work, not just stripes. I tried this pattern, but it looked too fussy to me, and I wanted something a little bolder. You can see this swatch is nowhere near six inches. It's probably 2 inches tall by maybe 3 or 4 wide? but it's one full repeat of the chart, which was enough to tell me it wasn't the vibe I wanted. I frogged and started again.
The colors reminded me of the sea at night, so I thought "what if I used an edging that looks like waves as the cuff, then worked the rest of the mitt perpendicular?" I liked the idea of the process, but this cuff was way too long, and bulky, and the picots I attempted at the junction just looked awkward. The stripes looked suitably nautical though, so I frogged and remixed once again.
This swatch got me where I wanted to be. The cuff looked "fancy" without being too fussy, it transitioned easily into the anchor motif (which I tried two variations of) and then I tried a different hem treatment at the top because I thought plain ribbing did not match the energy of the bottom cuff well enough. This is the swatch I took my numbers from and used it to create...
...these mitts. You can see the influences of each swatch along the way, and you can see how each stage was vital in obtaining the end result. "But," I hear some of you asking, "what if I don't want to do all that? What if I just want to make a nice hat or whatever?" I have the answer for that, too.
Sometimes, the Project is the Swatch
Yeah, that's right. I just said all those words at you, and for what? So that at the end I could say you don't have to do it anyway? Well, not exactly. If you are working on a small project, like mittens, socks, a hat, or even a scarf, there's nothing wrong with taking your best guess at the appropriate tools and starting numbers and just... going for it. If you're prepared to re-evaluate after a few inches, there's nothing wrong with starting even a sweater by starting with one sleeve. By the time you've finished the cuff and an inch or two of the arm, you'll have exactly the same data as if you had swatched. Especially if this is a yarn you use frequently or a pattern you return to often, your instincts combined with double checking yourself is a fine method, and one I've also used plenty of times.
When you should *not* use it is a different matter. I would suggest not using the project as the swatch in the following scenarios:
- If you're not prepared to check in at a certain point and re-evaluate. If you just want to start and be off to the races, it sounds counter intuitive, but swatching will actually get you there faster.
- If frogging your project back to the beginning is something that gives you hives, this method is definitely not for you in any circumstance. You are setting yourself up for frustration and disappointment, so be kind to yourself and treat the swatch as a mini-project for which there is no fail state. That way, when you get to the big project, you can be certain of your success.
- If the yarn is delicate and/or you have a limited amount of it, swatch first. There is nothing worse than losing yarn chicken, except for losing at yarn chicken with miles and miles of a lace mohair strand to frog. If you end up having to ditch a swatch's worth of yarn, that's usually less than a quarter of a skein. Still a big blow if you have limited yarn or the yarn was pricey, but doubly so if instead you have to rip back a whole yoke, which is potentially a whole skein or more, and find that the yarn is too enmeshed and you've lost the whole thing.
- You hate making the same thing more than once. Unless you're really lucky, you will be making this item at least twice. If that sounds like torture to you, swatch first. It sounds counter intuitive - isn't the swatch "doing it over again"? No, not if you treat the swatch as one, big, ongoing project which you add to to test colors, yarns, tools, and techniques on until you're satisfied you will be able to complete the "real" project. Doing your swatch in that way is different enough to the final project that it really will feel like a different project, I promise. I also feel like repeating a project is the same as having a tooth pulled (which is what lead me to learn the two-at-a-time method for socks and gloves, among other things), and I love swatching now because it really is a different project every time.
Conclusions
Swatching definitely has a bad rap, but that's just because a lot of people don't know how variable it can be and it becomes a terrible chore. But it doesn't have to be that way, and now you have the knowledge to turn swatching from "the awful slog at the beginning of your projects that is kind of pointless anyway because it always lies!" to a fun diversion that can become a fun project all on it's own, if you'd like. I hope this helped! If you have any questions or think there's something I can do to make this clearer or more educational, please let me know down in the comments!
No comments:
Post a Comment